Why the Price Tag Is Hard to Pin Down
Ask a company how much a patent lawsuit will cost and the honest answer is: it depends on how far it goes. A case that settles after an early motion might run a fraction of one that reaches a jury. The trouble is that most companies have to make spending decisions long before they know which kind of case they are in. Budgets get built on guesses, and the guesses are usually too low.
Jason Sheasby, a partner at Irell & Manella LLP, has tried more than ten complex patent and technology cases to verdict in less than two years, winning each one. That record puts him in a position few lawyers occupy: he has seen the full cost of a case play out, start to finish, across a wide range of industries and dollar amounts. His read on cost is not about hourly rates. It is about where the money actually goes, and when.
Legal Fees Are Just the Start
Outside counsel fees get the attention, but they are only one line in the ledger. Discovery alone can involve producing hundreds of thousands of documents, retaining forensic experts to pull data from old systems, and paying for depositions across multiple states or countries. Expert witnesses, who explain the technical and damages issues to a jury, charge for the time it takes to study the case, not just the time they spend testifying. On the other side, if a company loses, it can face the plaintiff’s damages award plus, in some cases, enhanced damages for willful infringement.
Fees also compound with delay. A case that could have resolved in a year but instead takes three years does not cost three times as much. It often costs more than that, because the work does not scale down evenly. Document review from year one has to be refreshed. Experts update their opinions. Witnesses who left the company have to be tracked down again.
The Time a Trial Takes From the Business Itself
The part companies underestimate most is not the invoice. It is the hours their own people lose. Engineers get pulled off product work to sit for depositions. Executives spend days preparing for and giving testimony. In-house teams spend months collecting documents and answering written discovery requests, work that has nothing to do with running the business.
This cost rarely shows up on a budget line, but it is real. A company with a lean engineering team can feel a six-person deposition schedule for months. The lawyers can manage the legal process, but they cannot do the employee’s job while that employee is preparing to testify.
Why Settling Looks Cheaper, and Sometimes Isn’t
Settling early often looks like the financially responsible choice. Sometimes it is. But a quick settlement, reached before either side understands the strength of its position, can lock a company into a bad number for years. Patent licenses and settlement terms frequently cover future products, not just the ones at issue in the suit. A company that settles cheaply to avoid near-term legal spend can end up paying far more over the life of the agreement than it would have spent litigating the case to a result it could live with.
The calculation changes again once a trial date is close. By then, both sides have spent most of the money they are going to spend regardless of outcome. Settling at that point only makes sense if the terms reflect how the case is likely to go, not how expensive the fight has already been.
What Sheasby Tells Companies Weighing the Decision
Sheasby’s view is that companies make better decisions about cost when they treat the case as a series of smaller decisions rather than one lump sum. Each stage, from filing through claim construction to trial, carries its own price and its own chance to reassess. Waiting until the end to ask whether the spending made sense is the mistake he sees most often.
Budgeting for a Case That Might Go the Distance
A workable budget accounts for three stages separately: discovery, pretrial motions, and trial itself. Each stage has a different cost profile. Discovery is the longest and often the most expensive in raw hours. Pretrial motions are shorter but concentrated, with intense work over a few months. Trial is the most expensive per week, but it is also the shortest stage in total time.
Companies that budget stage by stage can make real decisions at each checkpoint: settle, narrow the case, or push forward. Companies that budget for the whole case as one number tend to either overspend early, when they still believe it will settle, or run out of appetite right before trial, when the case is often strongest.
Questions to Ask Before the Spending Starts
Before committing to litigation, a company should ask what percentage of its engineering or product team will be needed for discovery, how long the relevant court typically takes to reach trial, and what a comparable case in the same technology area has cost from filing to verdict. None of these numbers are hard to find out in advance. They are just rarely asked until the invoices start arriving.
The real cost of a patent case is not a mystery. It is a sum of predictable stages, each with its own price, paid over a longer timeline than most companies plan for at the outset.
